Home › Procedures › What to Do When a Signer Refuses to

What to Do When a Signer Refuses to Sign One Page

A borrower has stopped mid-appointment and refuses to sign a specific document. Here is exactly what to do, who to call, and how to document what happened.

Why Partial Refusals Happen

Partial signing refusals — where a borrower signs most of the package but refuses one or more specific documents — are more common than full refusals. They typically occur when a borrower encounters a document whose terms differ from what they were told, a fee they weren't expecting, or a clause they don't understand and don't trust.

The most common trigger is the Closing Disclosure or the Affiliated Business Arrangement (AfBA) disclosure. Borrowers occasionally refuse to sign the AfBA because they believe signing it means they are agreeing to use a particular vendor — they are not. It is a disclosure, not a consent form. But this is a factual clarification you can make, not advice.

What You Cannot Do

You cannot pressure a borrower to sign any document. You cannot tell them the document doesn't matter or that refusing will cause problems for them. You cannot advise them on whether signing is in their interest. Your role is to facilitate the signing — not to advocate for the lender or the title company.

The Correct Procedure

  1. Stop the signing on that document. Set the refused document aside. Do not attempt to work around the refusal by signing other documents and returning to it.
  2. Calmly acknowledge the refusal. "I understand. Let me contact the title company so they can address your question directly." Do not argue or explain why the document is important to the lender.
  3. Call the title company or escrow officer immediately. This is not optional. The title company has authority to handle this; you do not. Explain the situation: "The borrower has declined to sign [document name]. They have [brief reason if given]. How do you want me to proceed?"
  4. Hand the phone to the borrower if directed. The title company or loan officer may want to speak directly with the borrower to clarify the document's purpose. Hand them the phone and step back.
  5. Document everything. Note in your records the name of the refused document, the time the refusal occurred, the name of the title company person you called, and the outcome.
  6. If the appointment cannot be completed, end it professionally. Do not leave documents with the borrower. If the title company instructs you to reschedule, confirm the instructions in writing before you leave.

Never Leave Documents Behind

If an appointment ends without all documents signed, the loan package must come back with you — not remain at the borrower's home. Documents left behind create a chain of custody problem and potentially a fraud exposure. Always return the complete package, signed and unsigned, to the title company or signing service.

Important: Some borrowers believe that if they hold the documents, they can negotiate changes. Retrieve all documents politely but firmly: "I need to bring the full package back — the title company will be in touch to reschedule."

Full Refusal — What Changes

If a borrower refuses to sign anything at all, the procedure is the same but more immediate: call the title company before attempting to retrieve documents. Do not leave. Do not argue. A calm, professional call to the title company is your first and only action.

Informational only. Not legal advice.

Frequently Asked Questions

In most cases, yes — your fee is for the appointment, not for a completed signing. Review the specific terms in your signing confirmation. Most signing services pay a partial fee (often called a "trip fee") for appointments that cannot complete due to borrower refusal. Document the refusal carefully so the signing service can process your payment claim.

You can explain what a document says in plain language. You cannot advise them on whether they should sign it. There is a meaningful difference between "This is an affiliated business arrangement disclosure — it informs you that [company] is affiliated with the lender, but signing it does not obligate you to use them" and "You should sign this because it doesn't really mean anything." The first is factual explanation; the second is advice and advocacy. Stay on the factual side.

If a borrower identifies what appears to be a genuine error — a wrong interest rate, a fee that wasn't disclosed, an incorrect party name — do not continue the signing. Call the title company immediately and describe what the borrower has found. This is not a refusal situation; it is a potential document error situation. The title company will need to verify the issue with the lender. Document exactly what the borrower pointed out and your call to the title company.

Related Guides